10 Best Italian Restaurants in West Virginia!

West Virginia is home to some of the best Italian restaurants in the nation. There is an Italian restaurant to suit every taste in the Mountain State, from simple pasta dishes to fancy dinners to fuel a night out on the town. Here are the 10 best Italian restaurants in West Virginia.

Figaretti's Restaurant, Wheeling, WV

Figaretti's Restaurant is an old-fashioned Italian joint where the family-run standby has offered traditional Italian plates for decades. And if you love their signature spaghetti sauce, don't worry — they have it for sale. One reviewer raves, "The BEST gnocchi in the USA."

Muriale's Italian Kitchen, Fairmont, WV

If you're looking for a hearty Italian meal, stop by Muriale's Italian Kitchen. In a comfortable, family-friendly room, the restaurant serves a scrumptious buffet filled with classic Italian eats like spaghetti and meatballs.

Rocco's Ristorante, Ceredo, WV

Rocco's Ristorante has been around in Kelly Hill for almost 40 years. The flavors and aromas that fill the air have drawn many loyal customers. "Food was amazing....the Lobster and crab ravioli had so much flavor," says one reviewer on Google.

Pasquale's, Beckley, WV

Pasquale's offers "good food, great atmosphere, and friendly staff" at a great price. The restaurant's menu includes various delicious Italian dishes, but their lasagne is the star.

Fazio's, Charleston, WV

Fazio's is a longstanding choice for authentic Italian cooking, with veal and steak options alongside classic plates of pasta. Foodies of all types will find something delicious on the menu in this relaxed room with a warm vibe.

Castiglia, Keyser, WV

Castiglia is a bustling Italian eatery offering super-sized portions of pizza, pasta, hot or cold subs, and burgers. Diners praise their "huge portions" and "delicious food," as well as the "friendly staff."

Oliverio's Ristorante, Bridgeport, WV

Oliverio's Ristorante brings flavors and food that go back for generations. From the streets of Calabria, Italy, to the hills of West Virginia, Oliverio's serves up homemade meatballs and is very close to Nonna's recipe.

Rocco's Little Italy, Huntington, WV

If you're looking for a delicious hoagie, Rocco's Little Italy has some of the best subs and Italian food in West Virginia. The "Boss" sandwich is a customer favorite, with Kelly Hill Original Rib-Eye, grilled onions, peppers, American cheese, and tomato.

Stefano's, Morgantown, WV

Stefano's is a great place to go to impress your date. The restaurant has a classy atmosphere and serves Italian-American dishes, steaks, seafood, and wine. They offer innovative weekly specials and a seasonally changing menu.

The Humble Tomato, Lewisburg, WV

The Humble Tomato boasts a classic red fireplace. One diner called their pizza "the best I've ever had (and I've been to Italy)." They're also a full-service Italian eatery serving light dishes with local ingredients, plus a full bar.

Share your favorites!
West Virginia Search
Find Italian Restaurants Near You
Select a West Virginia town to find
the Best Things-To-Do and Places To Go around you
Pleasants County